We Live in a Nightmare - Rated 
Charles Lindbergh is best known as the first person to fly solo across the Atlantic. However, he was also a noted isolationist and, prior to Japan's attack on Pearl Harbour, opposed any American involvement in the Second World War. Following the conviction of a German immigrant, Bruno Hauptmann, for the murder of Charles Jr, the Lindbergh family spend some time abroad, and become regular visitors to Germany in the late 1930s. Lindbergh refers to Hitler as "undoubtedly a great man", and receives the Service Cross of the German Eagle in 1938 from Hermann Goring. He continues to defend Nazi Germany after the invasions of Czechoslovakia and Poland and - in a speech in Des Moines, in September 1941 - identifies "the Jewish race" as one of the most influential groups in pushing America towards war. These groups are looking to enter the war, Lindbergh claims, "for reasons which are not American".
In real life, of course, Lindbergh's views made no real difference. America declared war on Japan, Germany and Italy after the attack on Pearl Harbour and, having once been a revered hero, Lindbergh fell rapidly from grace. He and his wife were widely viewed with distrust and even hostility - Charles was unwelcome in the Air Corps and work, for a time, work proved difficult to come by. However, things work out differently in "The Plot Against America" - which is probably best described as an alternate history book. In it, Roth imagines what his life might have been like if Lindbergh had stood for - and won - the American Presidency. However, rather than following the people in power, it imagines how Lindbergh's policies might have affected the Roth family.
The book covers a period of roughly two and a half years and opens in June 1940 - at a time when Roth was seven years old and a passionate stamp-collector. At this point, Roth was living in New Jersey with his parents and his brother Sandy - twelve years old, and a gifted artist. Up until Lindbergh's nomination for the Presidency, the Roth family led a largely happy life. They lived in a Jewish neighbourhood, something Roth's mother, Elizabeth, particularly appreciated. (Elizabeth had been raised in an Irish Catholic area, and - although she had never mentioned any blatant mistreatment - had grown up feeling something of an outsider). Although a Jewish quarter, it seems to have been typically `American' in appearance. Admittedly, the butcher was kosher - however, the language most commonly used was English rather than Hebrew or Yiddish, no-one wore a skullcap and few sported a beard. Philip, meanwhile, pledged his allegiance to America every morning at school, and couldn't see why Palestine was of any relevance. Life naturally changes dramatically under Lindbergh : an isolationist who had warned against "the infiltration of inferior blood", before negotiating an `understanding' with the Fuhrer. Not surprisingly, his subsequent policies are not designed with the best interests of the Jewish community in mind.
The man in charge of some of these policies is, essentially, a collaborator : Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf, of B'Nai Moshe Temple. A well educated and rich man, he had been viewed by the media as the religious leader of the Jewish people in New Jersey. However, he endorses Lindbergh's candidacy early in the book, effectively guarantees his victory and is subsequently `rewarded' with a post in government. As the Director of the "Office of American Absorption", he's responsible for the running of "Just Folks" - a program that takes Jewish teenagers, and sends them to live with Christian families for months at a time. In time, Sandy is selected and sent to a family in Kentucky, who run a tobacco farm - a stint that has a worrying effect on him. The Rabbi casts a long shadow over the Roth household as Elizabeth's sister, Aunt Evelyn, has a very close working relationship with the Rabbi. There are some friends and neighbours who look towards a life in Canada - others join the Canadian army to fight in the war. Among these is Roth's cousin, Alvin - who leaves early in the book - though soon returns home injured.
This is an excellent book - rather frightening, depressing and even a little challenging, but excellent nonetheless. Lindberg's government view their policies as the right and proper approach - they claim what they're doing will increase the American public's security and guarantee their well-being. People like Alvin - who fought in the war - are, on the other hand, somehow viewed unpatriotic. Early in the book the family take a trip to Washington, where his Roth's father highlights a line from the Gettysburg Address : "All Men Are Created Equal". In an instant, I was reminded of "Animal Farm" by George Orwell : "but some are more equal than others". Very highly recommended.
Gripping nearly all the way through - Rated
A gripping novel about the lifes and troubles of a Jewish family in an America that fortunately never was, where the extreme right wing aviator Charles Lindbergh stands for and wins the Presidency. Powerful stuff, though the explanation given for what motivated him in this parallel world, connected to the fate of his son, is rather implausible. Terrific stuff.
Vintage Roth - Rated 
This is one of his best. He envisions an America where President Charles Lindbergh reaches an accord with the Nazis, and the USA opts-out of WWII. The consequences for America's jews are played out out in the rest of the novel. Frighteningly believable, especially given the current Madness of Crowds that characterises the US body politic.
Odd and frustrating - Rated 
I can't say I got on with my first encounter with Mr Roth's work. I found this a curious piece, in large part coming across as biography - fine, if not that exciting - but then erratically conjoined with counter-factual history. The point of the two coming together somewhat escapes me, as the Lindbergh anti-semitism/pro-Nazism thing is skimpily drawn and doesn't intersect with the fictional characters satisfactorily. As noted elsewhere in the reviews, the conclusion of the Lindbergh plot stream is not well drawn. The whole thing seems to me to a device to pad out a moderately interesting childhood biography into something that seems far more significant. Unfortunately, I couldn't find the significance.
I also didn't particularly enjoy Roth's prose from a readability standpoint. Just not me I suppose.
worthy but not sure it is worth a read - Rated 
Audacious idea to re-write history and convincing up to a point and yet... I found this book a chore to read with lots of boring, overly detailed and ultimately irrelevant descriptions. The ending was a complete let down. Just as it is reaching a climax of sorts, Roth actually writes something like 'and then it was all over just like that'. This is followed by pages and pages of a fake historical account of what happens next in order to get it back on track with real history. While I can appreciate that the book is an astonishing feat of the imagination on one level, I would not recommend it as a good read. I also found his unpleasant observations on other religions such as Catholicism, made the character [and Roth] seem less symphathetic to the reader.
|
