No calm old age for Nathan Zuckerman - Rated 
Exit Ghost was published a year or so ago, but I've been putting off reading it, while also knowing that it was inevitable that sooner or later I would find myself once again in the company of Nathan Zuckerman, the "hero" of Roths's excellent "The Human Stain".
There is much more to this book that I have written below but I am always conscious of the need not to spoil the book for other readers. The outline of the story below is little more than can be found on the inside of the jacket.
In Exit Ghost, we find Zuckerman aged 70+, and returning to New York to receive treatment for incontinence. We read that he had exiled himself to a small house by a marsh for the last eleven years, and had cut himself off not only physically from his old life, but also going to the extent of cancelling his subcriptions to magazines and newspapers and only listening to the radio for its music.
In New York, the elderly author finds himself immediately sucked into the life of the city, reliving conflicts, relationships and literary controversies that were so much a part of his working life years before. This novel is primarily about aging, and Philip Roth from time to time quotes T S Eliots Little Gidding:
Let me disclose the gifts reserved for age
To set a crown upon your lifetime's effort.
. . . the bitter tastelessness of shadow fruit
As body and soul begin to fall asunder.
For while Zuckerman's mind and desires still seem to draw him back into his earlier life and activities, his body and brain sadly let him down at every stage, leaving only the "conscious impotence of rage at human folly", not least his own.
In fact, everything has crumbled. Zuckerman gets drawn into the possibility of a house exchange with a young couple who want to get away from the city for a year or so. He becomes sexually obsessed with the young woman, despite her obvious happiness with her husband, and his own post-prostate impotence and incontinence. He returns to his hotel after meeting her and writes down the imaginary conversations he would have had with her had his powers not deserted him, revealing that something of youthful desire lives on long after the physical capabilites of fulfilling them have long-since disappeared.
He is approached by the young biographer of a long-dead author who in Zuckerman's youth was his mentor, and finds himself outraged that the young writer is doing the usual digging around for human interest and hints of scandal rather than restricting himself to the literary development of Zuckerman's mentor. Zuckerman fails to see that what he loathes about the biographer Klinsman are precisely the traits which he himself carried in years gone by. The virility and agressiveness of Klinsman seems to bring out a passionate hatred and anger in Zuckerman which can only come from a man who is desparately rejecting the decay he is himself experiencing.
Exit Ghost is not a happy book. Zuckerman looks in as though through a cloudy window on a vibrant world of people forging their careers and reputations, one which gave him so much delight in his earlier years but one from which he is himself excluded. He seems unable to receive the consolation of later years when one is content to reflect on the past and enjoy the different pleasures which come from freedom from the constant striving which ambition brings.
Zuckerman is an immensely sad figure, adapted to his lonliness and isolation, but always aware that the smallest re-engagement with current literary life can start him off again, raging and arguing, fulfilling his craving for the admiration of men and the attentions of women. Complete withdrawal seems to be the only answer, but not a withdrawal to a comfortable life of peaceful satisfaction, but a sort of angry silence where the demons are held at bay only by constant self-denial of the things that provoke them.
A brilliant book of course, painful, difficult at times, even agonising, but it would be a terrible shame to miss it.
The Final Chapter - Rated 
"In a Mobius striptease, the disrobing stripper is always on the point of getting dressed again, and there is no resolution to the revelation.
'A Mobius striptease in written form, Philip Roth's new novel, "Exit Ghost," is purportedly his long-running character Nathan Zuckerman's new novel, narrated in the first person. During the course of Nathan Zuckerman's new novel, Zuckerman raises the question of whether an author's personal biography should ever be drawn into any discussion about his works of art. The answer seems to be that any reader who might want to do so must be a bit of a klutz." Clive James
Nathan Zuckerman, Philip Roth's, alter ego is lucky in one aspect- he does not die as the character did in 'Everyman'. He is , however, forever asking the question should his life be memorialized in book form. Really, it does not matter to me. This book fell short because of the continued quest for truth in advertising. Nathan is 71, lives in upstate Massachusetts, he is a loner and is seemingly satisfied by this lifestyle. He goes to his old stomping grounds, NYC, to undergo a procedure to alleviate the leakage of urine from a prostatectomy. He is hopeful this will be successful. While he is in New York he inadvertently reads an ad to exchange homes for a year. Something clicks and he finds himself in an apartment of a young couple and has made a deal to switch apartments. What does this mean? How did this happen? The rest of the novel essentially revolves around the couple, this decision and an author friend of Nathans. In reality Nathan's life is swimming before his eyes and his sexuality that he has lost is remembered to the full. The novel gets lost sometimes within these story lines and frankly becomes boring. There are conversations that take place in Nathan's mind. Philip Roth has always been fascinated by and with sex. Every book is filled with women that the main character fantasizes about. This is no different, fantasies aplenty. Fulfillment, well wait and see.
"Exit Ghost." Great title. The book of a great writer. A great book? Maybe it's just another piece of a puzzle. A great puzzle, and true to life in being so. In these strange and wonderful books that he writes under or about another name than his, Roth has been mapping the geography in an area of life where only his literary heroes ." Clive James
A book that is fascinating. It titillates and disappoints. It bores and it refreshes. It is the final chapter of Nathan Zuckerman. Adios.
Recommended prisrob 11-30-07
Gone for good - Rated 
First of all let me say that you shouldn't read this novel until you have read The Ghost Writer. In The Ghost Writer, the first novel to feature Nathan Zuckerman, the young writer travelled from New York to the Berkshires to visit his hero E.I.Lonoff. In Exit Ghost, which is probably the final appearance of Roth's alter ego, the journey is reversed and after 11 years in rural exile Zuckerman returns to the city, 'where the biggest thing of all occurred', on the eve of the presidential election which, we know, will put Bush back in the White House.
I had banished my country, been myself banished from erotic contact with women, and was lost through battle fatigue to the world of love.
He has made the journey, impotent and incontinent after prostate surgery, to undergo a procedure that he hopes will return to him some control over his bladder. It is the latest in the series of mortifications which we have endured with Zuckerman and another stripping away of the vitality and virility which has been such a huge part of him. Face to face with modern life again he surprises himself by responding to a house-swap advert from a young writerly couple looking for solitude, allowing his return to the city. But confronted with ghosts from his past his attempt to re-engage with the world is doomed to be a futile gesture.
Along with the surprise of making impulsive decisions comes the surprising reawakening of his sexual self. Jamie the young female writer exerts 'a huge gravitational pull on the ghost of my desire' but where the mind is willing the body is unable 'I experienced the bitter helplessness of a taunted old man dying to be whole again'. But the problem here is that the mind isn't even that willing anymore. Zuckerman's encounters with Jamie come in the form of imagined dialogues which lack character, insight and any real teeth at all.
He also encounters the woman who played such a thrilling part in the first novel, Amy Bellette, whom Zuckerman re imagined as an Anne Frank who had survived her fate. Now at the age of 75 she is transformed into a crazy looking woman in customised hospital gown with head half shaved and an ugly scaracross her scalp, a horrific transformation from the woman who had so charged the young Zuckerman's creativity. Having survived her lover Lonoff she is being hounded (as will Zuckerman) by Kliman, a young writer who wishes to write a biography of Lonoff containing the 'big secret' he had kept from everyone. Zuckerman's battles with this arrogant, pushy reminder of his own youth are the closest we get to fireworks. 'You're dying old man you'll soon be dead! You smell of decay. You smell like death!' he shouts to a urine soakedZuckerman.
Roth writes very well about what it is like to be a man losing his potency, both physically and mentally but the problem with having such a debilitated hero is that the writing as a whole suffers. Reading the dialogues between Zuckerman and Jamie is like reading a bad play script. Towards the end of the novel there is a section eulogising George Plimpton which comes from nowhere and feels very out of place. Roth is still better than most writers even when not on top form but there isn't much fun to be had reading a writer writing about how hard it has become to write.
Roth has written much better work (I really recommend The Counterlife and American Pastoral) and whilst those who are already fans will find much to admire it seems unlikely that Exit Ghost will convert any doubters.
Giving up the ghost - Rated
I've not necessarily warmed to Roth's alter ego, Nathan Zuckerman, in the past, having found the device less than successful in The Human Stain, though I enjoyed it more in American Pastoral, which was, in my opinion, a superior work. This new, and last, Zuckerman novel, Exit Ghost, has at its centre the argument against the biographical morality of an author's life being used as a lens through which to view the aesthetic merit of his or her work. It's written with some bitterness in places, which isn't a criticism at all, because Roth/Zuckerman makes some interesting points which I'm inclined to agree with, but it will of course raise the question with critics and readers alike that Zuckerman is Roth and Roth is Zuckerman and this is precisely the point that Roth/Zuckerman is endeavouring to dispute. But that's the beauty of Roth - his literary points are far from simplistic, he uses literature as a polemic, and the reader is as inclined to follow him as to reject him.
The novel itself is quite thin, with a literary battle being fought between Zuckerman and a young upstart, Richard Kliman, over the reputation of a long dead and forgotten author, E.I. Lonoff, whom Zuckerman admires and Kliman believes was guilty of private immorality, though the novel never establishes the "truth", instead using this plot as the platform for the argument about a writer's private life being used as a weapon against his public work.
In addition, the novel deals with the declining health of old age (as in his previous novel, Everyman) and lastly, and least successfully, with Zuckerman's infatuation with a much younger woman. Although Roth spares us the nausea of this sexy young thing submitting to the withered old man of letters, one can't help thinking it's an interlude that the author places into the novel to titillate himself, because in the real world the young woman's reaction would be "eugh". Notwithstanding this criticism, I was carried through the novel by Roth's fluid prose, and found it thought provoking and interesting throughout, so would recommend it heartily to readers looking for a book with which they'll have an enjoyable argument.
Glad Roth Worked in Comments about George Plimption - Rated
Nathan Zuckerman suffers from impotence and incontinence. His coping strategy is to withdraw from life's hubbub and to focus on his writing. But then the development of a new urological treatment brings him back into life and the subject of EXIT GHOST becomes: Who is Nathan Zuckerman, really?
To be fair, this Nathan does show concern and generosity for the sick. But the promise of physical rejuvenation transforms him--at least in his thoughts--into an overbearing sexual predator. This is not as offensive as it sounds, since Jamie Logan is a highly competent 30 and clearly represents the youth that the decrepit Zuckerman seeks desperately to regain. He's a jerk; she can handle it.
At the same, Jamie, and life in New York, does stimulate Nathan's obsessive mind, which brings awesome intelligence, unwavering focus, and a purity of analysis to whatever he discusses. But for most of the book, this relentless intelligence overanalyzes and crowds out the warmth.
Some of my marginalia in reaction to this Nathan reads: "Even the characters call this interaction a deposition!" "The interaction is so focused there's no juice." "I'm impatient with the narrative." "Interminable." For this reason, I read EXIT GHOST in 20 or 30 page snatches. This is a short book but it can read long.
Fortunately, Roth gives a Nathan a friendship with George Plimpton, the founding editor of "The Paris Review". Near the end of EXIT GHOST, Nathan describes Plimpton as an "urbane witty gentleman of easy intelligence and aristocratic bearing." And, when Plimpton is the subject, Nathan's obsessiveness explores life with great feeling, generosity, graciousness, and affection.
Granted, Roth takes Plimpton and what he represents and tucks him under the umbrella of his themes: the decay of body and mind, the easy power of youth, and the mighty pull and effects of a charismatic person. Regardless, Plimpton gives Roth a chance to show how wonderful Nathan's intelligence and imagination can be.
I began this book with sympathy for Nathan and his physical plight. After a long journey, I finished EXIT GHOST with admiration for Nathan and the rich potential of his awareness. In the end, the novel becomes much more than several (Nathan/Jamie, Kliman/Lonoff, Amy/Lonoff, Billy/Jamie) pathetic and slightly mad pursuits.
Final point: Keep Reading! Chapter 4, "My Brain" is Nathan's "last love scene" and it's fantastic.
|
