A chalet in the mountains ! - Rated 
I have had this book in my chalet since the beginning of the season on the coffee table and everyone who has read it has loved it..
given that it is the first time Pat and Vanessa have published it,I think it will get better and better..
The top 50 ski and snowboard resorts in europe - Rated 
My friends and myself thought this was a great buy! It has really helped us decided on our resort for this winter. I have used other ski and snowdoard guides in the past and this is by far the best! Why? This book has some amazing picture's and lets you know all about the latest hot equipment and top resort with loads of info you will not find anywhere eles. The authors seem to know there stuff and also give information for the younger generation that alot of other guides do not. This is the first travel guide ive read that lets you know about all the major competions in Europe. If you are in your 20, 30 or 40,s and you love your snowboarding and skiing and need help finding your best resort, this book is for you!
The top 50 ski and snowboard resorts in europe - Rated 
My friends and myself thought this book was a great buy! It really helped us decide on our resort for this winter. Why? Its filled with loads of amazing pictures of some of the worlds best skiers and boarders which you dont find in many travel guides. It has all the latest info for each resort they write about. Lets you know about all the latest equipment. This is the first snowboard and ski travel guide ive read that seems to have information for the younger generation. If your into your riding as much as me and need halp finding the best reort for you, then check this book out!
Well-Produced but Lacking Content, Quality Photos &Insights - Rated 
Essentially, this book feels like it was written by some guys who had 2 months and a digital camera to tour the Alps -- but ran out of cash and drank to much booze to finish the project. It's more of a travel diary than a knowledgeable guide book. I thought it was a waste of my money. Big time!
However, I need to give solid reasons why I dislike this book so much.
1. Resort Descriptions. Too short. Too stereotypical.
Only 1-2 paragraphs are used to describe a resort (lifts, pistes, mountains, snowfall, weather). This provides no information. There are very few insights and lots of stereotypes. You already know what they are going to say about some resorts: Courchevel 1850 - rich. Chamonix - good off-piste. Cortina - well-dressed Italians. La Grave - rugged. Zermatt - the Matterhorn is pretty.
2. Questionable Expert Knowledge.
It was obvious the authors were visiting many of the resorts for the first time and for very short periods.
For example, they spent ONE day at La Grave and did maybe 2 runs. They want to return. Glad you had a good time guys, but can you tell me something about La Grave? Please?
Val Thorens review seemed to be cut short because there was no snow when they went there. Sucks for us readers. No snow = no report. Well, just a short report. The pictures look really rocky at Val Thorens. Glad they did not ruin their skis/boards trying to do research.
3. Repeated Resorts.
The title is Top 50 Ski Resorts. However, what if you only had time and money to visit 47 places? You simply stretch them into 50 resorts. For example: How many would count Courchevel 1850, Courchevel 1650 and La Tania as 3 very different places? No one. They are all part of Courchevel. Why do they do this? Because one of the author's family owns a place in Courchevel 1650.
Some very popular places like Megeve, Murren, St. Moritz and Alp d'Huez are left out of the book - instead to focus on 3 different bases for the larger resort of Courchevel. Ridiculous.
4. Repeated Photos.
The same picture of Tignes resort is used over and over again -- almost 3-to-4 times in the Tignes review in the space of 4-5 pages. Same photo on every page. What is going on here? The photo is not just repeated...it is triplicated? Bizarre - who edited this book? I was in disbelief.
5. Poor Quality Photos.
Some very poor quality, grainy photos. Bad camera resolution. Also, they took a lot of photos on cloudy/stormy days with a lot of flat light. They also took the camera out drunk at bars and included random pics in dark clubs. Weird.
6. Sometimes a Map/Sometimes Not.
Sometimes they included a map of the resort -- most often they did not. What happened? Maybe they lost some piste maps on the way home? I'm paying good money for you to include the maps.
7. Advertising.
There are ads in the book. Kind of like infomercials masked as product reviews. I think ad execs from Salomon, Atomic, etc wrote these parts.
What did I like about the book?
1. Glossy Production.
It looks nice. Like a coffee table book. But the photos inside are not as good as the front/back covers.
2. Author's voice.
I liked that this was not some snotty old fart writing about his holidays in the Alps. However, there was not enough substance there. I can get to Snowheads.com and get better and free advice.
Maybe "Top 50 Ski & Snowboard Resorts" will get better...but I just do not know how it improves without some major work. New photos are needed. Better information included.
I was legitimately upset that I wasted my money on this book. Instead, I really liked "Where to Ski and Snowboard 2006". This book includes maps, real insights about the resorts and lengthy descriptions. There are some other ski books that are good/OK - like Ski/Snowboard Europe or The Good Book of Skiing.
|