the best dog behaviour book I have read - Rated 
Culture clash is without doubt the best dog behaviour book I have read and I have read A LOT!
It is well worth buying.
A seminal 'must read' for all dog owners - Rated
This is one of those 'change your life' books for dog owners - often the first they come to that clearly and concisely sets out the species differences in language that makes sense and should stop forever the inane (but common) assumptions that a) dogs are furry children, b) they speak English from birth, c) they can read their owner's mind and d) if they don't immediately do what the owner wants, they're being deliberately difficult.
It's well written, thoughtful, intelligent, funny and immensely compassionate with a clear care for dogs at its core. Definitely read it.
DISAPPOINTING - Rated 
AFTER ALL THE GOOD REVIEWS I READ I WAS SURPRISED TO FIND THAT THIS BOOK DID NOT LIVE UP TO EXPECTATIONS AT ALL. IT IS BADLY WRITTEN AND OVERLY COMPLICATED.
Confused - dig for the nuggets. Jean is a dog lover not an author. - Rated 
A strange book, which unfortunately seems to be based on really sound principles, but loses lots of marks for its strange style and layout. The book is a mix of a classic "how to" train/modify dog behaviours, social commentary on how society treats dogs, and some behavioural psychology which explains why dogs do certain things.
As many reviewers have commented, the social side of things is a bit off-putting, and while as a dog owner I fully agree with the underlying sentiment (don't punish dogs for being dogs!), the way in which this is blended in with the psychology and training material is unhelpful to the reader. It is also interesting to note the authour has a huge amount of sympathy for dogs, but seems to show no such understanding for well meaning owners that have simply been wrongly taught themselves.
The behaviour section is where the book is strongest, and the book explains the causes of common dog behaviours very well. If this is your main interest then I recommend this book.
If however you are more interested in training, I can't recommend this book. While there is good information is buried deep in the book, the illogical layout and lack of index mean that it is largely useless as a training reference book. If it is training you are after, I suggest a book on clicker training (by Karen Pryor), as this approach is at the heart of this book too.
All in all, the book comes across as written by someone who (i) deeply understands dogs and trains them very well, (ii) is very frustrated that society does not share this understanding or ability, and (iii) is a terrible author, which is a shame.
Culture Clash Review - Rated
I really wish I had bought this book when we got our puppy. It covers everything and we are getting results from all her methods. I have mentioned it to our local dog trainer and he recommends it too.
It is a really good buy and the only criticism may be that it is quite wordy and specific on psychology. However, once you find the problems you are experiencing, the solutions are very easy to understand and carry out.
|
